yea my miami futures for afc east, afc, and superbowl are fucked.
I still have them winning 9 games if they can beat either Chicago or Oakland (I think they split, probably beat lose to Chi and then beat Oak). The drop off from Henne/Pennington to Thigpen is not as bad as you think.
But you are assuming the offensive line of Miami who had Pennington and Henne killed in the same game will adequate protect Thigpen who is not a big guy.
I'd say whoever they pick up as backup will come in at some point in the next couple weeks when Thigpen is out for season.